In Part 2 of “Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis,” we dig into five states where home insurers posted extremely low loss ratios in 2025: Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine, and Florida. We highlight the major insurers with the lowest loss ratios in those states and review their average rate increases over the last five years. This analysis reveals that even as insurers were making high profits, they continued to raise rates with little regulatory scrutiny.
Home Insurance Companies Raised Rates With Little or No State Objection, Despite Falling Loss Ratios
Although home insurance premiums climbed to a greater degree than claims payouts between 2021 and 2025, many states continued to allow carriers to raise premiums with little to no pushback (see Chart 5).
Chart 5. Home Insurers Raising Rates Despite Falling Loss Ratios, 2021-2025
Regulators differ in how closely they scrutinize rate increases, and the process and negotiations over hikes are largely opaque to the public in most states. Rate filings are hard to navigate, scattered across different state databases with confusing subsidiary names and in inconsistent formats (see Appendix B for methodology). That makes it hard for consumers to understand how their insurer compares to others or why their premiums are going up.
To examine these trends more closely, we focus on five states: Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine, and Florida. The first three stand out as states with both a top-10 decline in loss ratios and a top-10 increase in premium revenue from 2021 to 2025. In other words, insurers in these states are paying out a smaller share of premiums in claims even as the premiums they collected grew substantially. Together, they represent distinct regions with unique weather risks: Texas faces a wide range of hazards, including hurricanes, flooding, and hailstorms; Iowa is also exposed to hailstorms as well as tornadoes, derechos, and flooding; and Idaho faces frequent wildfires and hailstorms.
No state in the Northeast was in the top 10 for loss ratio decrease and premium revenue increase; we decided to further evaluate Maine as a state with consistently low loss ratios from 2021 through 2025. Finally, Florida is worth examining in its own right. The crisis of dwindling home insurance availability and affordability is especially pronounced in the state, and its response, centered on limiting the legal rights of policyholders, warrants closer attention.
At the state level, a few insurers stand out for having particularly low loss ratios concentrated in regional geographies, including Liberty Mutual in the Northeast, Midwest, and South; American Family in the Midwest, Farmers in the West, Chubb in New England, and Nationwide in the Mid-Atlantic (see Map 3). This might suggest that these insurers deploy more aggressive premium growth or cost containment strategies, such as claims denials, in these regions where they can rely on strong brand presence.
Map 3. Lowest Loss Ratio Home Insurer in 2025 (Minimum 3% State Market Share)
There is a different lowest loss-ratio insurer in each of the highlighted states in our analysis—Texas (Liberty Mutual), Iowa (American Family), Idaho (Farmers), Maine (Chubb), and Florida (Citizens). For each state, recent premium increases have been requested by these insurance carriers and were enacted with little or no objection by insurance commissioners, despite low or declining loss ratios.
Texas
The growing divergence between rising premium revenue and falling claims payouts is readily apparent in Texas. Home insurers increased premiums collected in the state by 78 percent over the past five years, from $11.2 billion in 2021 to $20 billion in 2025. Meanwhile, claims payouts decreased by 23 percent during the same period, from $11.7 billion to $9.1 billion (see Chart 6).
Chart 6. Growing Divergence Between Premiums and Claims Payouts in Texas, 2021-2025
Another way to visualize this pattern is to look at changes in the statewide loss ratio. In Texas, the share of premium revenue used to pay out claims declined by 56 percent, from 104.2 percent in 2021 to 45.5 percent in 2025 (see Chart 7).
Chart 7. Home Insurers Increased Premium Revenue by 78 Percent in Texas as Loss Ratio Fell by 56 Percent from 2021-2025
Of the major insurance companies in Texas, the Liberty Mutual group had the lowest loss ratio in 2025 at just under 30 percent. This came after years of large rate increases that far outpaced inflation and the growth of insured losses from 2021 through 2024.
Our review of recent rate filings uncovered at least nine companies that are part of the Liberty Mutual group that underwrite homeowners insurance lines in Texas. Two of these companies together underwrite over two thirds of Liberty Mutual Group’s home insurance market in the state: American Economy Insurance Company, marketed as Safeco Insurance through April 2026 (NAIC Company Code 19690) and Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company (NAIC Company Code 12484).
Rates are regulated by the Texas Department of Insurance under a “file-and-use” process, which allows the insurance commissioner a fixed number of days to review a rate filing and object, otherwise the insurer can implement the rate. American Economy Insurance Company, marketed as “Safeco Insurance” through April 2026, adjusted home insurance rates 12 times over the period with little objection, amounting to a net average 144 percent premium increase since 2021 (see Chart 8).1 For consumers, this means average premiums are roughly two and a half times average premiums in 2020, so a standard home insurance policy that cost $2,000 in 2020 would have ballooned to $4,969.2
Chart 8. Safeco, the Largest Liberty Mutual Group Company in Texas, Filed and Enacted With Little Regulator Objection a Cumulative 144 Percent Increase in Home Insurance Rates from 2021 to 2025
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company meanwhile raised rates seven times over the period with little objection, amounting to a net average 102 percent premium increase since 2021 on homeowners combined dwelling policies, more than doubling their customers’ annual premiums.3
From 2021 to 2025, Liberty Mutual group amassed almost six billion dollars in home insurance premiums from Texas homeowners and renters. The firm’s total underwriting income across the state during that period was $2.1 billion. Nearly 70 percent of that came in 2024 and 2025, when loss ratios were 59.2 percent and 30 percent, respectively.
Compared to an environment where rates are set so that losses are 80 percent of the premium,
Liberty Mutual generated an estimated $911.5 million in excess underwriting income across Texas between 2021 and 2025 (see Chart 9 and Table 8).
Chart 9. Liberty Mutual Made $912 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Texas Between 2021 and 2025
Table 8. Liberty Mutual Made $912 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Texas Between 2021 and 2025
Iowa
Over the past two years, a gap emerged in Iowa between premium revenue, which continued to rise, and claims payouts, which fell (see Chart 10). Home insurers increased premiums collected in the state by 78 percent over the past five years, from $929.2 million in 2021 to $1.7 billion in 2025. Claims payouts decreased by 37 percent during the same period, from $895 million to $559.9 million.
Chart 10. Growing Divergence Between Premiums and Claims Payouts in Iowa, 2021-2025
Another way to visualize this pattern is to look at changes in the statewide loss ratio. In Iowa, the share of premium revenue used to pay out claims declined by 65 percent, from 96.3 percent in 2021 to 33.8 percent in 2025 (see Chart 11).
Chart 11. Home Insurers Increased Premium Revenue by 78 Percent in Iowa as Loss Ratio Fell by 65 Percent from 2021 to 2025
Of the major home insurers in Iowa, the American Family Insurance Company Group had the lowest loss ratio in 2025, at 23.4 percent. As in Texas, this loss ratio came after years of large rate increases that far outpaced inflation from 2021 through 2024.
Two companies together underwrite the bulk of the group’s home insurance market share in the state: American Family Insurance Company (NAIC Company Code 10386) and American Family Insurance Company Mutual Insurance Company Stock Investor (SI) (NAIC Company Code 19275).
Rates are regulated by the Iowa Insurance Division under a “use-and-file” process which allows insurers to immediately raise rates upon filing, and allows the insurance commissioner a fixed number of days to review and object. In Iowa, American Family Insurance Company adjusted homeowners rates five times, amounting to a net average 96 percent premium increase since 2021, nearly doubling annual premiums for their customers (see Chart 12).4
Chart 12. American Family Insurance Company Filed, and the Regulator Approved, a Cumulative 96 Percent Increase in Home Insurance Rates from 2021 to 2025
American Family Insurance Company Mutual Insurance Company Stock Investor raised rates six times, amounting to a net average 58 percent premium increase since 2021 in aggregate for homeowners, condo owners, and renters.5 According to the Iowa Insurance Division, the average homeowners insurance premium statewide in 2020 was $998.
The American Family group collected almost $584 million in home insurance premiums from Iowa policyholders between 2021 and 2025. The company’s total statewide underwriting income during that period was $210.9 million. Over 90 percent of that came in 2024 and 2025, when loss ratios were 50.1 percent and 23.4 percent, respectively.
From 2021 to 2025, American Family generated an estimated $94.1 million in excess underwriting income, compared with a scenario in which the company’s statewide loss ratio had been 80 percent each year (see Chart 13 and Table 9).
Chart 13. American Family Made $94 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Iowa Between 2021 and 2025
Table 9. American Family Made $94 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Iowa Between 2021 and 2025
Idaho
In Idaho, claims payouts have stagnated as premium revenue continues to rise. Home insurers increased premiums collected in the state by 90 percent over the past five years, from $482.2 million in 2021 to $914.3 million in 2025. During the same period, claims payouts grew by only six percent, from $348 million to $370.6 million (see Chart 14).
Chart 14. Growing Divergence Between Premiums and Claims Payouts in Idaho, 2021-2025
Another way to visualize this pattern is to look at changes in the statewide loss ratio. In Idaho, the share of premium revenue used to pay out claims declined by 44 percent, from 72.2 percent in 2021 to 40.5 percent in 2025 (see Chart 15).
Chart 15. Home Insurers Increased Premium Revenue by 90 Percent in Idaho as Loss Ratio Fell by 44 Percent from 2021 to 2025
Of the major home insurers in Idaho, the Farmers Insurance Group had the lowest loss ratio in 2025 at 27.6 percent.
The major Farmers Insurance Group insurers in Idaho are called Farmers Insurance Company of Idaho (NAIC Company Code 21601) and Farmers Insurance Exchange (NAIC Company Code 21652), which cover the bulk of the group’s market share in the state for home insurance lines and file for rate changes together.
Rates are regulated by the Idaho Department of Insurance under a “use-and-file” process. In Idaho, Farmers Insurance Company of Idaho and Farmers Insurance Exchange adjusted homeowners lines rates seven times without objection, amounting to a net average 66.2 percent premium increase since 2021 (see Chart 16).6
Chart 16. Farmers’ Two Largest Companies in Idaho Filed and Enacted Without Regulator Objection a Cumulative 66 Percent Increase in Home Insurance Rates from 2021 to 2025
From 2021 to 2025, Farmers brought in nearly $353 million in home insurance premiums from Idaho homeowners and renters. The firm’s total underwriting income across the state during that period was $165.7 million. More than two-thirds of that was generated in 2024 and 2025, when loss ratios were 41.1 percent and 27.6 percent, respectively.
From 2021 to 2025, Farmers generated an estimated $95.2 million in excess underwriting income, compared with a scenario in which the company’s statewide loss ratio had been 80 percent each year (see Chart 17 and Table 10).
Chart 17. Farmers Made $95 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Idaho Between 2021 and 2025
Table 10. Farmers Made $95 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Idaho Between 2021 and 2025
Maine
Although the gap between home insurance premium revenue and claims payouts is not growing as noticeably in Maine as it is elsewhere, it has remained large over the past five years owing to the state’s consistently low loss ratio. Premiums collected in the state increased by 45 percent, from $480.8 million in 2021 to $695.1 million in 2025. During the same period, claims payouts increased by 40 percent, from $158.2 million to $222 million. These factors grew in tandem, but insurers paid out small shares of premium revenue to policyholders each year (see Chart 18).
Chart 18. Consistent Gap Between Premiums and Claims Payouts in Maine, 2021-2025
Another way to visualize this pattern is to look at changes in the statewide loss ratio. In Maine, the share of premium revenue used to pay out claims remained low from 2021 to 2025, averaging 41.2 percent (see Chart 19).
Chart 19. Home Insurers Increased Premium Revenue by 45 Percent in Maine as Loss Ratio Fell by 3 Percent from 2021 to 2025
Of the major home insurers in Maine, Chubb Limited Group had the lowest loss ratio in 2025 at 12.9 percent, significantly lower than that of other major insurers in the state. Within the Chubb group, Great Northern Insurance Company (NAIC Company Code 20303) and Pacific Indemnity Company (NAIC Company Code 20346) write the bulk of Chubb’s home insurance business in the state, and they file for rate increases together with two other companies: Federal Insurance Company (NAIC Company Code 20281) and Vigilant Insurance Company (NAIC Company Code 20397).
Rates are regulated by the Maine Bureau of Insurance under a “file-and-use” process. These four companies adjusted rates three times since 2021, resulting in a cumulative increase of 37.5 percent.7 The rate changes for Chubb’s affiliates reflect changes to its proprietary Masterpiece homeowners insurance line, its primary offering in Maine, which is primarily marketed to high-end customers (see Chart 20).
Chart 20. Chubb’s Four Largest Companies in Maine Filed, and the Regulator Approved, a Cumulative 38 Percent Increase in Home Insurance Rates from 2021 to 2025
Chubb collected $136.4 million in home insurance premiums from Maine homeowners and renters between 2021 and 2025. The group’s total statewide underwriting income during that period was $104.3 million. Remarkably, its loss ratio never exceeded 32.7 percent.
From 2021 to 2025, Chubb generated an estimated $77 million in excess underwriting income, compared with a scenario in which the company’s statewide loss ratio had been 80 percent each year (see Chart 21 and Table 11).
Chart 21. Chubb Made $77 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Maine Between 2021 and 2025
Table 11. Chubb Made $77 Million in Excess Underwriting Income in Maine Between 2021 and 2025
Florida
In Florida, home insurance premium revenue and claims payouts have diverged sharply in recent years. Home insurers increased premiums collected in the state by 64 percent over the past five years, from $11.4 billion in 2021 to $18.7 billion in 2025. Claims payouts decreased by 67 percent during the same period, from $6.5 billion to $2.1 billion. Specifically, this gap has grown since 2023 (see Chart 22).
Chart 22. Growing Divergence Between Premiums and Claims Payouts in Florida, 2021-2025
Another way to visualize this pattern is to look at changes in the statewide loss ratio. In Florida, the share of premium revenue used to pay out claims declined by 80 percent, from 56.4 percent in 2021 to 11.4 percent in 2025 (see Chart 23).
No hurricanes made landfall in the U.S. in 2025, which contributed to extremely low loss ratios in the state, though insurers also had low loss ratios in 2024 when the state had high hurricane activity. Nonetheless, the high cost of reinsurance and the risk of especially damaging hurricanes requires insurers to purchase reinsurance to cover severe hurricanes, and may require additional reserves to promote solvency.
Chart 23. Home Insurers Increased Premium Revenue by 64 Percent in Florida as Loss Ratio Fell by 80 Percent from 2021 to 2025
In 2025, Citizens Property Insurance—the state insurer of last resort—was the largest home insurer in Florida, with $1.5 billion in direct premiums written, representing eight percent of the state’s market share. The loss ratio in 2025 dropped significantly to 9.3 percent, from 71.2 percent in 2024, well below levels seen earlier in the decade.
As the insurer of last resort, Citizens files for homeowners’ rate changes with the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation annually. Since 2023 legislation (SB 2-A), Citizens’ rate increases are bound by law to stay below similar private-market rates. Florida statute also caps how much any single policy’s rate can increase in a given year, known as the “glide path”: 12 percent in 2023, 13 percent in 2024, 14 percent in 2025, and 15 percent for 2026 and all subsequent years.
A 2023 Florida law, HB 799, requires that Citizens Property Insurance Corporation policyholders dispute claims in Florida’s Division of Administrative Hearings (DOAH) rather than a circuit court. This process of forced arbitration benefits the insurer; consequently, Citizens won 90 percent of claims disputes, compared with 55 percent in circuit court trials before the law passed. The statute also exposes policyholders to potentially tens of thousands of dollars in attorneys’ fees and restricts their ability to withdraw or appeal claims. The majority of final settlements resulted in measly sums of less than $500. While loss ratios decreased in part due to a more favorable legal environment that made it easier for Citizens to deny claims, Citizens also adjusted homeowners’ rates five times since 2021, with the changes resulting in a cumulative net average rate increase of 30.4 percent (see Chart 24).
Chart 24. Citizens Requested, and Florida Approved, a Cumulative 19 Percent Increase in Home Insurance Rates from 2021 to 2025
From 2021 to 2025, Citizens brought in $10.7 billion in home insurance premiums from Florida homeowners and renters. The carrier’s total underwriting income across the state during that period was $4.3 billion. Roughly 85 percent of that came in 2025 and 2023, thanks to respective annual loss ratios of 9.3 percent and 39.4 percent.
Compared with what would have happened had there been a minimum loss ratio of 80 percent each year, Citizens generated an estimated $2.1 billion in excess underwriting income across Florida between 2021 and 2025 (see Chart 25 and Table 12).
Chart 25. Citizens Property Insurance Made $2.1 Billion in Excess Underwriting Income in Florida Between 2021 and 2025
Table 12. Citizens Property Insurance Made $2.1 Billion in Excess Underwriting Income in Florida Between 2021 and 2025
- See Appendix B for a full list of rate filings. ↩︎
- We chose a baseline policy cost of $2000. The average homeowners policy premium in Texas in 2020 according to the Texas Department of Insurance was $1987. We do not know the 2020 average policy cost for American Economy Insurance Company because this information is not available. But we include here a simulation (see Appendix B for more information) of the increases that an average American Economy Insurance Company policyholder would have experienced if they paid $2000 for their policy in 2020, for illustrative purposes.
↩︎ - See Appendix B for a full list of rate filings. ↩︎
- See Appendix B for a full list of rate filings. ↩︎
- See Appendix B for a full list of rate filings. ↩︎
- See Appendix B for a full list of rate filings. ↩︎
- See Appendix B for a full list of rate filings. ↩︎
Report: Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis
For years, homeowners have been told skyrocketing insurance premiums are an inevitable consequence of climate change and inflation. Insurers have blamed more frequent and costly disasters for aggressively raising rates and withdrawing from markets.
This report lays out how the latest data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows soaring insurance costs cannot be fully explained by rising climate impacts, reinsurance, or construction costs. Excessive industry spending on overhead like executive compensation, advertising, and shareholder dividends, and record high profits are also to blame for climbing insurance prices. Meanwhile, insurers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for.
Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis was written by (alphabetically) Alex Martin, Dustin Duong, Elyse Schupak, Kenny Stancil, Lois Parshley, Mekedas Belayneh. It was edited by Aditi Sen, Annie Norman, David Arkush, and Jeff Hauser and published in November 2026.