Americans for Financial Reform
November 19, 2026

Report: Part 3

Excess Underwriting Income Could Have Been Used to Fund Climate Adaptation

From the report, "Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis"

In Part 3, we identify opportunities for insurer investment in adaptation in the states mentioned above. A small fraction of the excess underwriting income generated by the insurance industry since 2021 could help hundreds of thousands or even millions of households adapt to growing climate risks if reinvested in or granted for adaptation measures. These investments in adaptation can also help keep insurance affordable and available.

While curbing property insurance profiteering will bring costs down and provide consumer relief in the short term, climate change will continue to increase the risk of property damage from increasingly severe and frequent disasters for decades to come. The long-term affordability and availability of home insurance depends on climate mitigation, including global efforts to phase out fossil fuels, and climate adaptation, or investments in resilience to better withstand the impacts of climate change.

Adaptation projects at the property level, community level, or landscape scale can protect communities from climate damages and lower risks and insurance costs. The property insurance industry has funded the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS), which conducts research into cost-effective resilience measures, but has been sluggish to invest in the evidence-based solutions emerging from IBHS unless required to do so by states. The industry could do far more to fund adaptation at scale and to reward property owners for adaptation efforts they undertake, including through premium discounts and continuing coverage.

Even if only a small fraction of the industry’s excess underwriting income was reinvested in communities to support adaptation efforts, it would make an enormous difference in preserving people’s ability to stay insured. Had 10 percent of excess underwriting income been directed towards climate adaptation from 2021 through 2025, it would have provided nearly five billion dollars each year for adaptation projects, far more than FEMA’s annual spending on pre-disaster mitigation.

In a previous section, we estimated that home insurers made nearly $113 billion nationwide in excess underwriting income from 2021 to 2025. That is enough money to fund 11.3 million standard roof fortification matching grants valued at $10,000, providing grants to over a third of the estimated 33.1 million U.S. homes facing moderate or greater hurricane wind risk. Below, we quantify how many specific resilience projects could have been funded by particular companies’ excess underwriting income in Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine, and Florida.

Liberty Mutual’s $912 million in excess underwriting income could help protect Western and Gulf Coast Texas.

According to the U.S. Climate Vulnerability Index, Texas faces greater risks from climate impacts than 37 other states. At least 309 census tracts in Texas, home to 3.3 million households, are more vulnerable to climate impacts than 80 percent of the rest of the country. These fall into distinct regions that experience different, but related, climate vulnerability. Over 200 tracts across West Texas are prone to extreme temperatures, drought, and wildfire. Some of the regions in this area are more prone to climate impacts than almost anywhere else in the country, falling into the 99th percentile of vulnerability. The remaining tracts lie along the Gulf Coast and are set to encounter worsening floods and hurricanes. Like West Texas and its heat-amplified disasters, many regions here are in low-lying coastal areas and are more prone to climate impacts than 99 percent of the rest of the country. Some of these tracts include regions in and around some of the state’s largest cities, such as Houston, El Paso, Corpus Christi, and Lubbock. 

Between 2021 and 2025, Texas had 37,961 wildfires across over 2.4 million acres. The largest in the state’s history, the Smokehouse Creek Fire, began near the Texas Panhandle, one of these highly climate vulnerable regions, in 2024.In total, the fire burned through 1.05 million acres across Texas and Oklahoma, destroying around 500 buildings and killing two people and more than 15,000 cattle. 

Texas was also hit by the second-costliest hurricane in the United States. Hurricane Harvey made landfall in Texas in 2017 along the coast and caused over $125 billion in damage and at least 89 deaths. The top 20 ZIP Codes filing applications for disaster assistance in the storm’s wake lay along the zone that is most vulnerable to climate impacts.

Liberty Mutual, which had the lowest loss ratio of major Texas home insurers in 2025, made an estimated $912 million in excess underwriting income from policyholders in the state between 2021 and 2025. This money could have helped fund major infrastructure projects targeting climate adaptation across the state. 

These excess profits could fund more than twice what’s needed for a proposed landmark climate resilience fund, hardening as many as 80,000 homes. In July 2026, Governor Greg Abbott initiated a legislative push to create a $400 million fund that would issue $10,000 grants to single-family homes to retrofit their roofs to meet the FORTIFIED standard set by IBHS. Liberty Mutual’s excess underwriting income alone could fund over twice that amount, replacing roofs on at least 80,000 homes.

All property insurers operating in the state together could generate over 12 times that amount of hazard mitigation. The $11.2 billion in excess underwriting income over the last five years could provide roof fortification grants for 1.12 million households, accounting for more than a third of single-family homes in Texas neighborhoods at the highest level of risk.

American Family’s $94 million in excess underwriting income could help hail-proof Iowa homes. 

According to the U.S. Climate Vulnerability Index, Idaho is more vulnerable to climate impacts than 34 other states. At least 48 of the state’s census tracts are in the 80th percentile of climate impact vulnerability, concentrated in central and southern Iowa. These areas, home to nearly 100,000 households and near the state’s major cities, face extreme temperatures and hail-producing storms. Since 2020, Iowa has reported hail over 2,000 times, representing four  percent of all the hail reported across the entire country during the same time period. 

American Family, which had the lowest loss ratio of major Iowa home insurers in 2025, made an estimated $94 million in excess underwriting income from the state’s policyholders between 2021 and 2025. This sum could help fund climate adaptation grants offered by the state or retrofits for individual homes, such as: 

  • 1000 $10,000 grants for communities and for-profit businesses to “promote preparedness and resilience.” ($10,000,000) Iowa City offers Community Climate Action Grants of up to $10,000 for nonprofits, community-based organizations, and for-profit businesses to help implement the city’s Climate Action and Adaptation Plan. Eligible projects promote “preparedness and resilience” or “sustainable activities.” While this particular grant program is intended to benefit Iowa City residents, similar programs could be established by other municipalities,.
  • Up to 5,600 roof replacements for individual homeowners. ($84,000,000) Some general contractors in the state estimate that a roof replacement with Class 4 impact-resistant shingles, which are ideal for regions that frequently see severe hail, can cost between $15,000 and $22,000. 

Altogether, American Family alone could fund thousands of grants and home retrofits for thousands of people across Iowa. All property insurers operating in the state together could generate 3.6 times that amount of hazard mitigation from the $339 million in excess underwriting income generated between 2021 to 2025. 

Farmers Insurance’s $95 million in excess underwriting income could help fire-proof Idaho homes and communities.

According to the U.S. Climate Vulnerability Index, Idaho is more vulnerable to climate impacts than 20 other states. At least seven census tracts across the state are in the 80th percentile of climate impact vulnerability, home to over 10,000 households. Many of these tracts are situated in the southern half of the state, which is particularly prone to a combination of extreme heat and wildfires. 

In July 2026, the Scorp Fire burned across more than 4,700 acres in Southern Idaho, in a region with a higher wildfire risk than almost anywhere else in the country. Nineteen years prior, in 2007, the second-largest fire in Idaho history scorched 650,000 acres across the southern part of the state as well as parts of Nevada. 

A portion of insurers’ excess underwriting income could go toward protecting hundreds of communities and hundreds of thousands of homes from these risks. 

Farmers Insurance, which had the lowest loss ratio of major Idaho insurers in 2025, made an estimated $95 million in excess underwriting income from the state’s policyholders between 2021 and 2025. This sum could help fund a variety of Idaho’s climate adaptation grants offered to communities through the state, such as: 

  • 100 $240,000 grants supporting communities with wildfire resistance plans. ($24,000,000) The Idaho Department of Lands offers Hazard Fuels Reduction (HFR) grants of up to $240,000 to state, county or local agencies, nonprofits, tribes, and educational institutions to pursue fire risk mitigation projects in areas with designated County Wildfire Protection Plans (CWPP) or similar documents. Similarly, the Department of Lands also administers money through the Western States Fire Managers Program. These grants are used to fund the creation of defensible space around homes and structures and to support slash removal, prescribed fires, monitoring, and plan development, AND
  • 100 $250,000 grants helping low-income communities improve landscape resilience. ($25,000,000) The Idaho Department of Lands administers the Private Forest Protection, Resilience, and Restoration Assistance (PRRA) Program. State, county, and local agencies, nonprofits, tribes, and educational institutions can receive up to $250,000 to promote resilience and restoration in alignment with Idaho’s State Forest Action Plan in areas that are considered “underserved communities” or low-income by the United States Forest Service AND
  • 9,000 $2,500 Firewise Grants for individual landowners and communities to expand wildfire treatment areas. ($22,500,000) Places like Valley County, Idaho, administer grants through the Firewise program to help landowners or communities reduce wildfire risk. The Valley County Wildfire Mitigation Department specifically offers up to $2,500 and expects a 50:50 cost-share AND
  • 11,750 $2,000 grants to support wildfire initiatives for up to 176,250 homes. ($23,500,000) Idaho Firewise’s Community Ambassador Partnership Program currently offers reimbursements for hosting a community chipping event, intended to destroy flammable vegetation on privately owned property. Homeowners associations and community organizations are eligible for up to $2,000 per event serving 10-15 residents. 

Altogether, Farmers alone could fund grants for thousands of people and communities across Idaho to lower their wildfire risk. All property insurers operating in the state together could generate over seven times that amount of hazard mitigation with their $738 million in excess underwriting income from 2021 to 2025. 

Chubb’s $77 million in excess underwriting income could help shore up 7,700 Maine homes.

According to the U.S. Climate Vulnerability Index, Maine ranks higher in climate impact vulnerability than over half of other states in the nation. Thousands of homes across the state experience impacts from severe storms and flooding. 

Chubb, which had the lowest loss ratio of major Maine home insurers in 2025, made an estimated $77 million in excess underwriting income from policyholders in the state between 2021 and 2025. This could help fund climate adaptation grants, such as:

  • Grants for 7,700 households to upgrade their roofs or mitigate flood risk. Maine has established a climate adaptation program called the Fortify Maine Homes Program, which provides grants for Maine residents to install FORTIFIED roofs—which meet the resilience standards set by the Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS)—or for flood mitigation activities such as retrofitting electrical wiring, sealing ground level openings and foundations, and installing drains. Homeowners can receive $10,000 grants, which can be raised to $15,000 for low-income households.

Chubb alone could fund retrofits for thousands of homes across Maine. All the companies in the state together could generate over 14 times that amount of hazard mitigation with their $1.1 billion in excess underwriting income from 2021 to 2025, and provide Fortify Maine Homes Program grants to 110,000 households, representing about 21 percent of Maine’s single family housing stock.

Citizens’ $2.1 billion in excess underwriting income could shore up Florida homes against hurricanes.

According to the U.S. Climate Vulnerability Index, Florida is more vulnerable to climate impacts than 29 other states. At least 143 census tracts on or near the coast are more vulnerable to climate impacts than at least 80 percent of the rest of the country, representing at least 3.8 million households. One of the biggest threats to homes on Florida’s coasts are climate-intensified hurricanes and flooding, threatening major cities such as Jacksonville, Miami, Tampa, St. Petersburg, Ft. Lauderdale and others. 

From 2021 to 2024, Florida had 11 billion-dollar tropical cyclones, 14 billion-dollar storms, and two billion-dollar flood events, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. These cost Floridians up to $306 billion in damages. Hurricane Ian, one of the largest storms in recent U.S. history, made continental landfall in southwestern Florida in 2022. Ian especially endangered the large number of mobile homes in the region; in Lee County alone, over 5,000 mobile homes were destroyed. 

Florida Citizens, which had the lowest loss ratio of major Florida home insurers in 2025, made an estimated $2.14 billion in excess underwriting income from Florida home insurance policyholders from 2021 to 2025. This amount would be enough to fund a significant number of climate resiliency grants in the state, such as:

  • 211,865 My Safe Florida Homes Grants. ($2,000,000,000) To protect homeowners against hurricane losses, Florida developed and operates a successful climate adaptation program called My Safe Florida Homes, which provides free wind mitigation inspections and matching grants that support qualifying resilience improvements, including stronger roofs, roof-to-wall connections, opening protection, and secondary water barriers. Since 2022, the program has provided matching grants covering up to $10,000 (with cost share requirements eliminated for low-income households) for hurricane retrofits, protecting over 39,000 households at a cost of $369 million dollars. The state is now running a similar pilot program to protect condominiums, offering up to $175,000 per association AND
  •  All 73 Resilient Florida Planning Grants issued to municipalities in FY2025-26. ($21,344,355) The Florida Department of Environmental Protection also awards planning grants, intended to support projects addressing flooding, sea level rise, and other resiliency efforts across entire communities and regions. Cities and counties can apply for and receive varying funding amounts, according to their needs, projects, and progress. In fiscal year 2025-26, municipalities across the state received $21,344,355 in funding. The largest grant, $1.4 million, went to fund a real-time flood forecasting system for Lee County.

Florida Citizens alone could fund retrofits for hundreds of thousands of homes across Florida. Florida home insurers in aggregate made $20.7 billion in excess underwriting income from 2021 to 2025. This excess underwriting income could fund My Safe Florida Homes grants for an additional 2,068,367 households, representing about 34 percent of Florida’s single family housing stock. 

Report: Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis

For years, homeowners have been told skyrocketing insurance premiums are an inevitable consequence of climate change and inflation. Insurers have blamed more frequent and costly disasters for aggressively raising rates and withdrawing from markets.

This report lays out how the latest data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows soaring insurance costs cannot be fully explained by rising climate impacts, reinsurance, or construction costs. Excessive industry spending on overhead like executive compensation, advertising, and shareholder dividends, and record high profits are also to blame for climbing insurance prices. Meanwhile, insurers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for.

Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis was written by (alphabetically) Alex Martin, Dustin Duong, Elyse Schupak, Kenny Stancil, Lois Parshley, Mekedas Belayneh. It was edited by Aditi Sen, Annie Norman, David Arkush, and Jeff Hauser and published in November 2026.

Report Logos