Americans for Financial Reform
November 19, 2026

Report: Appendix B

Rate Filings

From the report, "Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis"

A major goal of insurance reform should be to provide the public with accessible, generally comprehensible data that allows them to meaningfully compare different insurance companies along the key dimensions that consumers care about: their claims handling track record and how well their prices reflect the value these companies return to policyholders. Insurance consumers should not need to be experts to understand why their rates are going up, or how their increases compare to others’ across the state.

In general, it can be difficult for consumers, researchers, and policymakers to fully understand the property insurance rate filing process, the actuarial data underpinning rate hikes, why rates are rising so quickly and for whom, and how the financial health of individual insurers and their parent companies factor into the process.

The public is generally familiar with the names of major insurance groups—the parent companies that advertise during the Super Bowl—but these insurance groups often own handfuls of state-level subsidiaries and affiliates, some with recognizable names, but others which can appear totally unrelated. Some companies file rates under different names than their brand name, so the first challenge for a consumer trying to understand their rate hike is finding out the actual name of their insurer as filed with the state insurance regulator.

If the state insurance department website provides a link to the NAIC’s SERFF database, the consumer might find their way to a specific webpage where they can search rate filings in their state, though even this link is sometimes hard to find. From there, rate filings’ documents and criteria are handled differently in each state, resulting in non-standardized sets of forms and actuarial exhibits. Companies sometimes file for rate increases for all homeowners’ insurance lines simultaneously and sometimes for just a subset (e.g., only renters insurance). The percentage for statewide average premium increase attributed to an individual rate filing are sometimes rolled up to an aggregate number that covers all homeowners lines (HO-1 through HO-8), while sometimes these percentages are listed just for a particular line. We attempted to compile rate filings for individual companies and document our methodology below, which differs slightly state to state given the different availability of comprehensible information and variable business structures.  

Qualitatively, it is clear upon reviewing forms in a variety of states that different state insurance regulators subject rate filings to variable levels of scrutiny, allowing for different levels of projected underwriting profits, approving hikes at different speeds, asking more or fewer questions of insurers to justify their requests, and providing different levels of transparency for the public. Some of these state-level discrepancies are due to statutory differences, but some appear to be due to the inclinations of different insurance commissioners themselves and the capacity of their departments.

Across companies and states, insurers usually claim their models suggest they need larger rate increases than those they actually file for (often denoted as “indicated” vs “selected” increases, respectively), despite the general trend we document in this report of decreasing loss ratios from 2021 to 2025 in each of these states. Departments of Insurance sometimes request more information and companies respond with more data and explanations. Back and forth negotiations, revealed in sequential documentation, between regulators and insurers are often more subjective than is commonly understood by the public and researchers and can be difficult to track across filings. Insurers very rarely formally adjusted or withdrew rate filings in the states we reviewed. Some states also do not clearly indicate whether a filing was approved and went into effect: For example, Texas tags filings in effect as “closed.”

From a consumer’s perspective, despite this nominal public access to NAIC’s SERFF rate filing database, it would be extremely difficult and time consuming—and sometimes impossible—to really understand why their rates are rising and how these increases compare to aggregate increases in the state or the rate hikes of other individual insurers. Different companies—even within the same insurance group—raise rates at quite different speeds, and consumers might have been pushed towards one subsidiary over another when they applied for coverage, not knowing the price would diverge later.

The result of this tangle of data, existing in different locations and filed under different company names in different formats, is generally inscrutability. This limits the ability of the public to understand why rates are rising and to compare different companies. The Texas Department of Insurance maintains the most useful database we have seen to make rate filings more discernible, but cross referencing between its database and SERFF would still be necessary to understand, for example, which homeowners lines are covered under a particular filing and what parts of the rating manual are changing. 

Rate filing review methodology

We chose to review only homeowners multiperil owner-occupied policy lines (see here for descriptions), which do not comprise the entirety of the residential property insurance market. Flood, earthquake, force-placed, and dwelling fire (for rental properties, investment homes, or vacant dwellings where the owner does not primarily reside) are covered under different policies that the NAIC aggregates in separate sections of its market share reports. 

Generally, we reviewed rate filings using the NAIC SERFF database along with materials provided by state departments of insurance where available. Approximate state-wide market share in homeowners lines were established by reviewing all recent rate filings dating back to 2020 for all companies within the insurance groups in question within a state as identified in the NAIC’s 2025 market share report. We looked for the most recent mention of overall premiums written, usually available in a 2025 or 2026 rate filing. From there, we selected the large home insurance company or companies (by home insurance premium volume) operating in the state to review rate filings to determine the net impact on average statewide premiums for homeowners insurance lines from 2020 through present, and in the case of Texas, the average statewide premium increase for a hypothetical standard policy.

Texas

Texas rate filings were reviewed using the NAIC SERFF Texas database as well as the Texas Department of Insurance’s rate database and search tool. Where observed rate changes were available, we used those figures, and where not, we used the projected filed rate changes. Tables 13 and 14 below include the full range of rate filings we considered in Texas for the two Liberty Mutual group companies with the largest home insurance market share in Texas. 

Table 13. American Economy Insurance Company, marketed as Safeco Insurance through April 2026, (NAIC Company Code: 19690) homeowners increases in Texas since 2021. This company is the largest Liberty Mutual group company in Texas in the homeowners insurance lines. 

These rate changes were also confirmed retroactively by the company in Exhibit C in SERFF filing LBPM-134946965. This table includes rate changes in aggregate across all homeowners insurance lines (HO-1 through HO-8 policies), excluding two filings that only covered condo owner insurance rate increases.

Year SERFF FilingEffective date (renewal)Rate change observedNet rate change since 1/1/2021Annual direct loss ratio (group-wide)
2021LBPM-1326709577/9/218.6%8.6%113.5%
2022LBPM-1331732407/9/2211.0%20.5%65.8%
LBPM-1333086129/12/2210.2%32.8%
2023LBPM-1335253147/9/2312.0%48.8%74.0%
LBPM-1336324249/12/2312.0%66.6%
LBPM-13378975212/27/238.1%80.1%
2024LBPM-1338726652/20/2411.0%99.9%59.2%
LBPM-1339291494/24/243.0%105.9%
LBPM-1340325807/9/2416.2%139.3%
LBPM-1341184609/12/244.2%149.4%
2025LBPM-13464637711/25/25-2.0%144.4%30.0%
2026LBPM-1349469659/12/261.7%148.5%
Table 14. Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company (NAIC Company Code: 12484) homeowners combined dwelling rate increases in Texas since 2021. 

This company is the second largest Liberty mutual group affiliate in Texas in the homeowners insurance lines. These rate changes were also confirmed retroactively by the company in Exhibit C in SERFF filing LBPM-134968726. This table includes rate changes in aggregate across all homeowners combined dwelling policies.

Year SERFF FilingEffective date (renewal)Rate change filedNet rate change since 1/1/2021Annual direct loss ratio (group-wide)
2021LBPM-13257810303/20/216.4%6.4%113.5%
2022LBPM-13313834103/20/229.0%16.0%65.8%
LBPM-13333680508/30/2211.0%28.7%
2023LBPM-13344754003/20/239.0%40.3%74.0%
LBPM-13375206408/30/2321.0%69.8%
2024LBPM-13392606703/20/2417.0%98.7%59.2%
2025No rate changes98.7%30.0%
2026LBPM-13496872608/30/261.8%102.2%

Iowa

Iowa rate filings were reviewed using the NAIC SERFF Iowa database. The rate filings in Table 18 and 19 reflect all filings for the two largest American Family Group companies that had a net impact on their respective average statewide premiums for homeowners insurance lines (excluding renters, condo, and manufactured homeowners policies). Net rate changes for Table 18 were listed based on retrospective observed rate changes (as shown in SERFF filing AMFC-134576714 “Actuarial Memorandum Exhibit”) which differ slightly from the filed rate changes.

Table 15. American Family Insurance Company (NAIC Company Code: 10386) homeowners insurance premium increases in Iowa since 2021. 

These rate changes were also confirmed retroactively by the company in the Actuarial Memorandum Exhibit in SERFF filing AMFC-134576714. These rate changes reflect filed increases for homeowners insurance policies only, excluding renters, condo owners, and manufactured homeowners lines. 

Year SERFF FilingEffective date (renewal)Rate change observedNet rate change since 1/1/2021Annual direct loss ratio (group-wide)
2021AMFC-132958514 10/15/218.0%8.0%96.9%
2022AMFC-133384114 11/1/2215.1%24.3%84.5%
2023AMFC-133784750 11/1/2322.0%51.7%96.9%
2024AMFC-134172411 11/1/2430.5%97.9%50.1%
2025AMFC-134576714 11/1/25-0.9%96.1%23.4%
2026None96.1%
Table 16. American Family Insurance Company Mutual Insurance Company Stock Investor (SI) (NAIC Company Code: 19275) homeowners insurance premium increases in Iowa since 2021.

 These filings cover aggregate rate changes in the homeowners insurance lines, covering multiple homeowners insurance products ( “Goldstar,” which is the primary homeowners product, and “Custom Value and Forms 1, 2, 3”) and renters and condo owners policies. 

Year SERFF FilingEffective date (renewal)Rate change indicated in filingNet rate change since 1/1/21Annual direct loss ratio (group-wide)
2021AMFC-1328804669/1/214.5%4.5%96.9%
2022AMFC-1333182859/1/2211.0%16.0%84.5%
2023AMFC-1337330509/1/2311.0%28.8%96.9%
2024AMFC-1339492244/7/2414.8%47.8%50.1%
2024AMFC-13417110411/15/245.0%55.2%
2025AMFC-1345285179/1/251.8%58.0%23.4%
2026None requested58.0%

Idaho

Idaho rate filings were reviewed using the NAIC SERFF Idaho database. The rate filings in Table 17 reflect aggregate changes across all homeowners lines (HO-1 through HO-8) for the two companies which file for rate changes together, and which offer multiple homeowners products.

Table 17. Farmers Insurance Company of Idaho (NAIC Company Code: 21601) and Farmers Insurance Exchange (NAIC Company Code: 21652) homeowners insurance rate increases in Idaho since 2021. 

These two companies together make up the bulk of Farmers Insurance group’s homeowners insurance business in Idaho. Rate changes listed represent filed aggregate changes for all homeowners insurance lines offered by these carriers, including the Farmers Flex Personal Home policy, Farmers Smart Plan Home policy, and Farmers Smart Plan Condo policy, as well as other homeowners, condo owners, and renters policies.

Year SERFF FilingEffective date (renewal)Rate change filedNet rate change since 1/1/2021Annual direct homeowners loss ratio (group-wide)
2021FARM-1327602203/21/210.9%0.9%74.1%
2022FARM-1331969523/20/224.6%5.5%76.5%
2023FARM-1337077655/18/237.6%13.6%63.4%
FARM-13390856511/21/2321.9%38.4%
FARM-13392972712/16/233.7%43.6%
2024FARM-1341338365/18/2413.5%62.9%41.1%
2025FARM-13471519312/13/252.0%66.2%27.6%
2026None requested

Maine

Chubb rate filings were reviewed using the NAIC SERFF Maine database. Chubb affiliates filed rate increases jointly, so the analysis reflects their combined rate changes. Chubb offers its premier personal insurance program for higher-value homes in Maine called “Masterpiece.” The homeowners coverage is on the company’s own proprietary form with extras like extended replacement cost and water backup included as standard.

Table 18. Federal Insurance Company (20281), Great Northern Insurance Company (20303), Pacific Indemnity Company (20346), and Vigilant Insurance Company (20397) aggregate rate increases for the “Masterpiece” homeowners insurance product line in Maine since 2021, including Form/Coverages including “House/Vacation Home”, “R/C/C” and “Home Primary Liability.” 
Year SERFF FilingApproval or effective date (renewal)Rate change filedNet rate change since 1/1/2021Annual direct loss ratio (group-wide)
2021ACEH-132542849 Approval date: 11/12/2020; Effective date: likely early 202110.2%10.2%25.9%
2022None requested10.2%24.1%
2023ACEH-133436862Approval date: 12/9/2022; Effective date: likely early 202315.1%26.8%32.7%
2024None requested26.8%24.8%
2025ACEH-134296896Effective date: 4/3/258.4%37.5%12.5%
2026ACEH-134893235Approval date: 6/9/262.4%40.8%

Florida

Florida’s Citizens Property Insurance Corporation is the state insurer of last resort, and therefore its rates are subject to greater statutory limits and regulatory oversight. Citizens has statutory rate increase caps, which for 2026 limit rate increases to 15% for primary-residence personal policies. The rate changes reflected in Table 19 are for the established rates for HO-3, HO-4, and HO-6 policies, multiperil personal lines for single-family homeowners, renters, and condo owners, excluding high-risk coastal account policies. In 2024, coastal accounts made up less than 10% of the company’s multiperil homeowners lines business. Florida Citizens rate increases are listed separately for personal and commercial lines. Rate increases for Citizens also involve a more public process, including public hearings and opportunities for public comment.

Table 19. Citizens Property Insurance homeowners insurance rate increases in Florida since 2021 for personal HO-3, HO-4, and HO-6 policies, excluding high-risk coastal account policies. 
Year OIR Case No.Effective date (renewal)Established net rate changeNet rate change since 1/1/21Annual direct loss ratio (across all lines)
2021279215-218/1/213.2%3.2%44.8%
2022293112-229/1/226.4%9.8%144.4%
2023314719-2311/1/2311.3%22.2%39.9%
2024No Rate Change
2025030310-246/1/256.6%30.4%71.2%
2026056573-256/1/26-8.8%18.8%

Sources

  1. Hancock, Peter. “Insurance Industry Opposes Regulation, Blames Inflation and Climate Change for Rate Hikes.” Capitol News Illinois. August 21, 2025.
  2. Ge, Shan et al. “Climate Risk, Insurance Premiums, and the Effects on Mortgage and Credit Outcomes.” Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. January 2025.
  3. Roston, Eric. “Home Insurance Tops Property Taxes in Squeeze For US Households.” Bloomberg. October 20, 2026.
  4. Sastry, Parinitha et al. “The Limits of Insurance Demand and the Growing Protection Gap.” Harvard Business School. May 2025.
  5. Gunara, Maggie and Becca Stanek. “Nearly 1 in 7 Homes Across US Are Uninsured.” Lending Tree. March 2, 2026.
  6. National Association of Insurance Commissioners. “2025 Market Share Reports For Property/Casualty Groups and Companies by State and Countrywide.” August 2026.
  7. AM Best. “Best’s Market Segment Report: A Myriad of Factors Lead to Markedly Improved Homeowners Results.” September 28, 2026.
  8. Horton, Cassidy. “https://www.realtor.com/news/trends/home-insurance-crisis-nonrenewal-rates/.” Realtor.com. August 18, 2026. 
  9. Sisler, Tonya. “Experts say climate change is impacting home insurance: Do homeowners see it?” KIRO 7 News. October 28, 2026.
  10. Bogage, Jacob. “Home insurers cut natural disasters from policies over climate risk.” The Washington Post. September 3, 2023.
  11. Shearer, Brian. “How to Lower the Insurance “Tax” By $150 Billion.” Vanderbilt University. Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator. April 2026.
  12. Humphrey, Justin et al. “Federal Spending for Flood Adaptations.” Congressional Budget Office. September 2024.
  13. Riddle, Anne. “Funding for Wildfire Management: FY2025 Appropriations for Forest Service and Department of the Interior.” Congressional Review Service. September 12, 2025.
  14. Stancil, Kenny. “Mapping Home Insurance Regulation.” Revolving Door Project. March 17, 2026.
  15. Riley Roche, Lisa. “What is the state of housing in Utah?” Deseret News. September 9, 2026.
  16. AON. “2026 Climate and Catastrophe Insight.” 2026.
  17. AON. “Climate and Catastrophe Insight.” 2025.
  18. Verisk. “U.S. P&C Insurers Post Strong Underwriting Gains Through First Half of 2026; Line-Specific and Geographic Challenges Persist.” September 2, 2026.
  19. Brannon, Matt et al. “Insurify Projects Home Insurance Rates Will Rise for the 5th Consecutive Year, After a 12% Increase in 2025.” Insurify. 2026.
  20. Flavelle, Christopher. “Insurers Are Dropping Homeowners as Climate Shocks Worsen.” The New York Times. December 18, 2024.
  21. Eaglesham, Jean and Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky. “The Home-Insurance Coin Flip: Nearly Half of Claims Result in Zero Payout.” The Wall Street Journal. May 30, 2026.
  22. Black, Sam and Sydney Guthrie. “We Uncovered Where Your Insurance Payments Are Really Going.” More Perfect Union. August 14, 2026.
  23. Goldstein, Jacob. “Warren Buffett Explains The Genius Of The Float.” NPR. Planet Money. March 1, 2010. 
  24. Sclafane, Susanne. “What Progressive and GEICO Q3 Results Reveal About Auto Insurance Profit, Growth.” Insurance Journal. November 10, 2025.
  25. Shearer, Brian. “Property Insurance Has a Greedflation Problem.” Vanderbilt University. Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator. April 30, 2026.
  26. Delong, Michael and Douglas Heller. “Top Ten Insurance CEOs Earned Over $155 Million in Compensation in 2025, While Consumers Struggled to Pay Premiums.” Consumer Federation of America. October 20, 2026.
  27. Shearer, Brian. “Regulating Insurance as a Public Utility.” Vanderbilt University. Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator. April 2026.
  28. “Medical loss ratio.” Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Accessed November 2026.
  29. Carlson, Debbie. “HO-1 to HO-8: Comparing home insurance policy types.” Britannica Money. Accessed November 2026.
  30. Heller, Douglas and Michael Delong. “New Analysis: Homeowners Insurance Companies Earn Millions in Interest and Investment Income with Every Day of Claim Delay.” Consumer Federation of America. July 30, 2026.
  31. Keller, Yana. “Liberty Mutual retires Safeco brand, unifies personal insurance products.” Beinsure. October 28, 2026.
  32. Grubbs, Spencer and Kelly Langford. “Home insurance premiums complicate housing affordability.” Fiscal Notes. October 2024.
  33. Sellmeyer, Sonya. “Consumer Connection: Shopping for Homeowners Insurance.” Iowa Insurance Division. July 24, 2023.
  34. Ocean Point Claims Company. “Florida Statute 627.351: Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, FAQ.” Accessed November 2026.
  35. Ariza, Mario. “A Florida Home Insurer Was Allowed to Bypass the Courts During Claim Disputes. It Won More Than 90% of the Time.” ProPublica. September 15, 2025.
  36. Cotality. “Hurricane risk 2025: Outpriced and underwater.” May 29, 2025.
  37. Environmental Defense Fund, Texas A&M University, and Darkhorse Visualization. “The U.S. Climate Vulnerability Index.” Accessed November 2026.
  38. Texas A&M Forest Service. “Historical Fire Statistics.” Accessed November 2026.
  39. OroraTech. “2 Years After Smokehouse Creek Fire: What we Learned.” 2026.
  40. Fiscal Notes. “A Storm to Remember: Hurricane Harvey and the Texas Economy.” Accessed November 2026.
  41. Texas Division of Emergency Management. “HURRICANE HARVEY DR 4332.” Accessed November 2026.
  42. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration. “Hurricane Harvey: A Look Back Seven Years Later.” August 26, 2024.
  43. Pope, Jacob. “Gov. Abbott’s $400M Roof Fortification Plan — What Texas Homeowners Need to Know.” Donegan. July 21, 2026.
  44. Plain Hazard. “Iowa hail.” Accessed November 2026.
  45. Iowa City. “Climate Action Grants.” Accessed November 2026.
  46. Yates, Chad. “Iowa Roof Replacement Cost in 2026: What Homeowners Actually Pay.” Buckshot General Contracting. Updated October 2026.
  47. CBS 2 Idaho. “Scorp Fire burning thousands of acres near Murphy, Idaho.” July 26, 2026.
  48. Wildfire Risk to Communities. “Murphy has a very high risk of wildfire—higher than 98% of communities in the US.” US Department of Agriculture and US Forest Service. Accessed November 2026.
  49. Launchbaugh, Karen et al. “Interactions among livestock grazing, vegetation type, and fire behavior in the Murphy Wildland Fire Complex in Idaho and Nevada, July 2007.” US Geological Survey. September 7, 2008.
  50. Idaho Department of Lands. “Hazard Fuels Reduction Grants.” Accessed November 2026.
  51. Idaho Department of Lands. “FY26 HFR, FY27 WSFM Grant Programs Request for Proposals.” 2026.
  52. Idaho Department of Lands. “Private Forest Protection, Resilience, and Restoration Assistance.” Accessed November 2026.
  53. Valley County Idaho. “Building a Fire-Resilient Valley County.” Accessed November 2026.
  54. Idaho Firewise. “Community Ambassador Partnership.” Accessed November 2026.
  55. Maine Bureau of Insurance. “Fortify Maine Homes Program.” Accessed November 2026.
  56. Fortified 2025. “FORTIFIED Roof™.” Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety. Accessed November 2026.
  57. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration. National Center for Environmental Information. “Florida Summary.” Accessed November 2026.
  58. Widdekind, Andrew. “Financial & Population Damage Impacts from Hurricane Ian.” December 12, 2022.
  59. Olander, L. et al. “FORTIFIED Roof Case Study: Florida.” Duke University. Nicholas Institute for Energy, Environment, and Sustainability. 2026.
  60. Florida Department of Environmental Protection. “Exhibit A Progress Report Form – Planning Grants.” Accessed November 2026.
  61. Florida Department of Environmental Protection. “Fiscal Year 2025-26 Resilient Florida Planning Projects.” Accessed November 2026.
  62. Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund. “States Must Strengthen Oversight of Homeowners Insurance Rate Increases.” February 28, 2026.
  63. Stancil, Kenny and Dan Wagner. “Home Insurance Executives Are Raking It In—at Your Expense.” The American Prospect. July 23, 2025.
  64. Darmiento, Laurence. “State Farm accused of funneling excess profits to parent as it seeks rate hike.” LA Times. October 28, 2024.
  65. Schupak, Elyse and Carly Fabian. “Principles for Resilient Homes Grant Programs.” Public Citizen. June 9, 2026.
  66. Alabama Department of Insurance. “Strengthen Alabama Homes Application Portal.” Accessed November 2026.
  67. Colorado General Assembly. “HB25:1182 Risk Model Use in Property Insurance Policies.” 2025. 
  68. Oklahoma Office of Attorney General. “Drummond files lawsuit against Allstate Insurance Company.” July 7, 2026.
  69. Rosenfeld, Harvey. “Why Minimum Loss Ratios Don’t Work For Home Insurance.” Consumer Watchdog. September 15, 2026.
  70. Balber, Carmen. “State Farm’s Shady Reinsurance Deal.” Consumer Watchdog. November 8, 2024.
  71. Swisher, Skyler et al. “News organizations publish Florida’s secret examination of insurer profits.” Orlando Sentinel. September 26, 2026.
  72. National Association of Insurance Commissioners. “SERFF Filing Access for Texas.” Accessed November 2026.
  73. National Association of Insurance Commissioners. “Dwelling Fire, Homeowners Owner-Occupied, and Homeowners Tenant and Condominium/Cooperative Unit Owner’s Insurance Report: Data for 2023.” July 2026. 
  74. Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. “CITIZENS FILING FCP 24-030311 – COASTAL ACCOUNT – HOMEOWNERS STATEWIDE PROPOSED CHANGES BY POLICY TYPE.” Accessed November 2026.

Report: Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis

For years, homeowners have been told skyrocketing insurance premiums are an inevitable consequence of climate change and inflation. Insurers have blamed more frequent and costly disasters for aggressively raising rates and withdrawing from markets.

This report lays out how the latest data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows soaring insurance costs cannot be fully explained by rising climate impacts, reinsurance, or construction costs. Excessive industry spending on overhead like executive compensation, advertising, and shareholder dividends, and record high profits are also to blame for climbing insurance prices. Meanwhile, insurers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for.

Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis was written by (alphabetically) Alex Martin, Dustin Duong, Elyse Schupak, Kenny Stancil, Lois Parshley, Mekedas Belayneh. It was edited by Aditi Sen, Annie Norman, David Arkush, and Jeff Hauser and published in November 2026.

Report Logos