Americans for Financial Reform
November 19, 2026

Report: Part 4

Policy Recommendation

From the report, "Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis"

In Part 4, we make policy recommendations to address profiteering in the home insurance industry and promote climate adaptation. We recommend policymakers consider prior loss ratios in rate regulation, strengthen oversight of insurer rate increases, require insurers to invest in and reward climate resilience, increase oversight of insurer claims handling, and increase transparency over insurer underwriting, pricing, and claims decisions so consumers can meaningfully compare insurers.

Key Takeaways

  • Insurance regulators and state lawmakers must adequately oversee insurers to rein in bad behavior so that individual homeowners are not padding insurance industry profits in the midst of an affordability crisis and accelerating climate change. Rather than allow insurers to accrue record profits while communities pay the price, policymakers must:
    • establish a minimum loss ratio for property insurers
    • strengthen oversight of rate increases
    • require insurers to invest in and reward resilience
    • increase oversight of insurer claims handling, and
    • increase transparency over insurer underwriting, pricing, and claims decisions. 
  • Excess underwriting income should be used to support policyholders by funding a host of adaptation efforts in response to worsening wildfires, hurricanes, severe convective storms, and floods.
    • Home insurers made nearly $113 billion nationwide in excess underwriting income from 2021 to 2025. 
    • Excess underwriting income over the last five years could fund 11.3 million grants to help homeowners strengthen their roofs, valued at $10,000 each, reaching over a third of the estimated 33.1 million U.S. homes facing moderate or worse hurricane wind risk. 

As climate change makes disasters more widespread, severe, and costly—and threatens the affordability and availability of property insurance—regulators and policymakers must do a better job of protecting policyholders and communities. State insurance commissioners and legislators should work to prevent growing climate change impacts from being offloaded onto policyholders through rate increases, claims denials, and withdrawals while insurers make record profits. To do so, policymakers should consider prior loss ratios in rate regulation, strengthen oversight of insurer rate increases, require insurers to invest in and reward resilience, increase oversight of insurer claims handling, and increase transparency over insurer underwriting, pricing, and claims decisions.

Consider prior loss ratios in property insurance rate regulation

Federal or state governments should establish a minimum loss ratio (on a direct or net basis) for property insurers, setting a floor on the percentage of collected premiums that must be paid out in claims for insurers to remain in good standing, maintain licenses, and receive consideration for rate filings. Alternatively, insurance commissioners can more closely consider recent loss ratios when evaluating insurance company rate changes, and deny or challenge rate increases by firms with low loss ratios without new legislative action. Because insurance claims fluctuate widely from year to year, policymakers should consider loss ratios averaged over at least five years if establishing a minimum loss ratio or considering loss ratios more centrally in rate regulation. Policymakers may consider existing proposals to establish an 80 percent minimum net loss ratio on P&C insurers as a whole or establish a minimum loss ratio on specific insurance lines (i.e. home, auto, etc.). If established on the state level, policymakers should consider the appropriate loss ratio floor for their state based on risk and current market factors.  Establishing a minimum loss ratio will discourage excessive spending on advertising, dividends, fighting claims, and other non-essential costs, and promote claims payments above current levels. Insurance regulators can also cap these expenses outright rather than relying on a minimum loss ratio alone or prohibit expenses from being passed through to policyholders as rate increases.

Strengthen oversight of insurer rate increases and excess spending 

State insurance commissioners should increase their scrutiny of insurer rate increases and excess spending. In states where the insurance commissioner has the authority to approve or deny rate increases before they go into effect, insurance commissioners should use this authority to closely review and analyze profit margins, administrative costs, and investment income and deny excessive rate requests. When insurance companies have consecutive years of outsized profits, they should be required to either lower their rates or submit a justification for maintaining their current rates. Insurance commissioners should also scrutinize or outright cap excess spending that may not appear as profit, such as excessive executive compensation, spending on corporate jets, and excessive dividends and share buybacks, as well as methods used to funnel profits to affiliates, like purposefully overpaying for reinsurance. States that do not currently grant their insurance commissioner prior approval authority over rates should pass laws to do so, and provide avenues for meaningful public participation in the rate review process.

Require insurers to invest in and reward resilience 

States should incentivize investments in climate resilience by providing grant funding to homeowners for resilience upgrades. Ten states and counting have established grant programs to help homeowners make resilience upgrades to their property, including fortified roofs, wildfire mitigation, and flood mitigation. Many of these grant programs are modeled off the Strengthen Alabama Homes Program, through which owners of existing owner-occupied single-family homes in certain counties in Alabama are eligible for a grant up to $10,000 for a roof upgrade meeting the IBHS FORTIFIED Roof standard. In addition to funding property-level resilience projects, states should identify opportunities for insurers to pay into community- and landscape-scale resilience projects that can lower risks for insurers and communities alike. 

Funding for the Alabama program and several other state programs comes from fees or premium taxes on the insurance industry. States should increase fees or premium taxes on insurers operating in the state to fund grant programs that can save homeowners, property owners, insurers, and state governments money following disasters. State insurance regulators should require insurers to give homeowners discounts for upgrades that protect against disasters. They should also require insurers to account for home and community improvements that reduce wildfire and other catastrophe risks in both underwriting and pricing, much as Colorado did in 2025 enacting a bill entitled Risk Model Use In Property Insurance Policies. Insurers should also be required by states to take some portion of their investment returns and make funds available to policyholders to fortify their homes. While many existing grant programs are capped at $10,000 per recipient, states should consider larger grant amounts for low- and moderate-income homeowners to incentivize uptake from those with the most financial need.

Increase oversight of insurer claims handling

Insurance departments should increase oversight of insurer claims handling practices to ensure that policyholders receive the benefits of the insurance they pay for in the event of a disaster. When claims go unpaid, households are too often left to cover repair and rebuilding expenses themselves, despite having paid for insurance. Given the high rate of unpaid claims, insurance departments must increase oversight of insurer claims practices to ensure that policyholders are fairly paid. When insurance department oversight is insufficient, states should consider legal action against insurers. For example, the Oklahoma attorney general has recently sued State Farm and Allstate over an alleged scheme to systematically underpay claims. 

Increase transparency over insurer underwriting, pricing, and claims decisions

State insurance departments should maintain a public webpage to describe how the insurance rate-setting process works in plain language, and maintain a public schedule of hearings relating to rate-setting and methods for consumers to participate in the process. Insurance departments should also make public the full rate manual for each home insurance carrier operating in the state, and require insurers to file their full up-to-date rate manual with every rate filing, so insurance departments and the public can better understand pricing decisions. In the event an insurer would like to nonrenew a policy, they should be required to disclose to the policyholder the reason for nonrenewal in writing and the remedies the policyholder could take to stay insured by their current provider. States should extend nonrenewal notice periods to at least 90 days to provide sufficient time for policyholders to make upgrades to their property to stay insured. 

Insurance commissioners should also seek to provide consumers with data that allow them to meaningfully compare different insurance companies along the key dimensions that consumers care about, including their claims handling track record and how well their prices reflect the value these companies return to policyholders. Insurance consumers should not need to be experts to understand why their rates are going up or how their rate increases compare to others’ across the state. 

Accordingly, each state should create a searchable online database covering each individual insurer in the state, disaggregated for each homeowners insurance line, that includes total aggregate statewide increases in premium, average gross annual premiums per policy, loss ratios, and claims handling statistics. This database should cover at least the last five years and include any additional names the insurer uses across branding and rate filings.

Report: Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis

For years, homeowners have been told skyrocketing insurance premiums are an inevitable consequence of climate change and inflation. Insurers have blamed more frequent and costly disasters for aggressively raising rates and withdrawing from markets.

This report lays out how the latest data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows soaring insurance costs cannot be fully explained by rising climate impacts, reinsurance, or construction costs. Excessive industry spending on overhead like executive compensation, advertising, and shareholder dividends, and record high profits are also to blame for climbing insurance prices. Meanwhile, insurers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for.

Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis was written by (alphabetically) Alex Martin, Dustin Duong, Elyse Schupak, Kenny Stancil, Lois Parshley, Mekedas Belayneh. It was edited by Aditi Sen, Annie Norman, David Arkush, and Jeff Hauser and published in November 2026.

Report Logos