Americans for Financial Reform
November 19, 2026

Report: Part 1

National Home Insurance Trends

From the report, "Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis"

In Part 1 of this report, we analyze national trends in home insurance markets, including changes to premium revenue, loss ratios, claims payments, and excess underwriting income.

Home Insurance Premium Revenue Grew by 59 Percent—Over Twice as Much as Claims Payouts

In 2025, insurance companies earned $181.2 billion in premiums from homeowner multi-peril policies. That was up 59 percent from 2021, when the industry brought in $113.9 billion in premium revenue.

Map 1.

In Utah, the state with the largest increase in the study period, the industry collected about $690 million from households in 2021, rising to $1.34 billion in 2025—an increase of nearly $650 million in just five years (see Table 1). As a result, owning a home has become even more expensive in a state where housing is already unaffordable for many.

Table 1. Growth in Home Insurance Premiums Collected, 2021-2025

The increase in premium revenue is due to a variety of factors, including growth in the number of households, construction cost inflation, increasing home values, growing climate-related risks and the higher losses insurers expect as a result, and aggressive rate increases. 

Nationwide, in the study period, “direct losses,” the amount insurers pay out in claims, rather than the total economic damage caused by disasters, increased 28 percent in the U.S. home insurance market, jumping from $78.4 billion in 2021 to just over $100 billion in 2025. Global insurance and brokerage firm Aon estimates that weather-related disasters caused $141 billion in economic losses in the United States in 2025. That was down 35 percent from 2024, when losses reached $218 billion, but still above the 21st-century average of $117 billion. Even as insured losses rose between 2021 and 2025, premium revenue increased more than twice as much as claims payouts (see Chart 1). One estimate from the first half of 2026 suggests that this gap could grow further still.

Chart 1. Growing Divergence Between Premiums and Claims Payouts, 2021-2025

The divergence between insurers’ rising premiums and stalling claims payouts is driven by several factors. First, as discussed above, insurers have increased rates at an unprecedented pace from 2021 through 2025. For consumers,  premiums have increased by an estimated 46 percent since 2021. Second, insurers are withdrawing from climate-vulnerable communities. Companies are dropping properties in certain areas with heightened climate risk, in some cases, even if the homeowner has paid for resilience upgrades to their property. Third, insurers are delaying, underpaying, or failing to pay out the claims they owe, leaving people without the protection they paid for. Finally, there were relatively few high-cost catastrophe events in the U.S. in 2025, with the notable exception of the Los Angeles wildfires in January. This relative lull has helped insurers hold on to a greater share of premiums collected, improving financial results, but does not account for the entire rise in profitability.

Home Insurance Loss Ratios Fell by 20 Percent—Meaning Insurers Kept Greater Share of Premiums

The widening gap between higher premium growth and lower claims payouts benefits insurers by allowing them to keep a larger share of the money they collect from consumers. This is reflected in insurers’ loss ratios, or the percentage of premiums they pay out in claims. 

In 2025, the loss ratio in the U.S. home insurance market was 55.1 percent. This means that for every $100 insurers collected in premium revenue, they only paid out $55 in claims to policyholders and kept $45. That retained money can go toward legitimate business costs, like employee salaries, claims administration, reinsurance, and other necessary operating expenses. But insurers can also use it for discretionary spending, including advertising, executive compensation, perks like private jets, and legal expenses related to fighting policyholders so they don’t have to pay their claims. Such a low loss ratio maintained over multiple years suggests that insurers are charging policyholders too much, paying out too little in claims, or both.

There are several ways to measure profitability through loss ratios. One is looking at a company’s direct loss ratio, or how much a company pays out in claims compared to the premiums it collects. Another is to look at its net loss ratio, or the ratio of premiums collected paid out as claims after accounting for reinsurance costs. In this report, we  use direct loss ratios except where otherwise noted. (See Appendix A for further justification of analyzing loss ratios.)

Underwriting loss ratios do not include investment gains, which is a major source of insurance industry profits. Writing coverage gives insurers access to vast amounts of interest-free premium capital that they invest and in turn reap gains that are not usually shared back with policyholders. In fact, in a competitive market, modest underwriting losses are common, a price insurers pay for accessing policyholders’ premium dollars to invest in income generating assets. Insurers make investment returns on reserves and surpluses built up over time from premiums collected from policyholders.

The national home insurance loss ratio has steadily declined, falling from 68.8 percent in 2021 to 61.5 percent in 2024, and just 55.1 in 2025, and only 48.4 percent for the first half of 2026. The 2025 loss ratio was approximately 20 percent lower than in 2021 (see Chart 2).

Chart 2. Declining National-Level Loss Ratios, 2021-2025

In 2025, some states had exceptionally low loss ratios, meaning insurers held onto much of the premiums they collected. These include Hawaii, where insurers paid out just eight cents of every dollar collected in premiums (8%), Florida (11%), New Mexico (22%), Louisiana (23%), and South Carolina (26%) (see Table 2). 

Loss ratios naturally fluctuate from year to year, depending on the severity of disasters, especially in states seeing an increase in climate-related catastrophes. Changing weather patterns are increasing the risk of losses, meaning this volatility will likely increase. The industry  also moves through multi-year or decadal underwriting cycles, with periods of high premium growth and profit followed by more competitive pricing and lower profit. 

Despite this variability, several states have consistently had particularly low loss ratios. From 2021 to 2025, five-year average loss ratios were lowest in Massachusetts (37%), Maine (41%), New Hampshire (45%), Vermont (45%), and Rhode Island (47%) (see Map 2). Looking back even further, average loss ratios have dropped since the 1990s (see Chart 3), suggesting a structural shift where insurers return less benefit to policyholders. These trends extend beyond the normal swings of underwriting cycles and warrant greater regulatory scrutiny.

In the study period, insurers’ falling loss ratios translated to record corporate profits while policyholders struggled to pay their bills. The result is unnecessary financial strain for policyholders, including rising household debt and mortgage delinquencies, and growing risks to local economies and the broader financial system from uninsured and underinsured homes. 

Map 2. Average State-Level Loss Ratios, 2021-2025

States that saw the largest reductions in loss ratios were Louisiana (94% decrease), Hawaii (81% decrease), Florida (80% decrease), Colorado (66% decrease), Iowa (65% decrease), and New Mexico (60% decrease) (see Table 2). 
Table 2. Change in State-Level Loss Ratios, 2021-2025

Evidence of Home Insurance Price Gouging: Up to $113 Billion in Excess Underwriting Income

The industry’s preferred method of accounting for underwriting profitability is not loss ratios, but combined ratios. A combined ratio measures how much an insurer spends as a percentage of its premium revenue on claims, plus its operating expenses. It is calculated by adding the loss ratio and expense ratio, or the percentage of premiums a company spends on things like salaries and marketing. The combined ratio often approaches and occasionally exceeds 100 percent, allowing insurers to claim that they are barely breaking even. In reality, in healthy markets, insurers often primarily make their money on investments, so small underwriting losses are normal, and not a sign that prices are too low. Combined ratios are not a good measure of profitability because many of the included expenses—such as bloated advertising budgets, agent fees, money spent fighting claims, and soaring executive compensation—could be reduced or, in the case of private jet purchases, eliminated. 

A better way to assess whether insurers are generating excessive profits is to compare their actual loss ratios with a proposed minimum. In a revealing paper, Brian Shearer of the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator evaluated historical loss ratio data for the U.S. property and casualty insurance industry, and concluded that a fair average minimum loss ratio would be 80 percent, similar to that set for the health insurance industry, which saw declining loss ratios in years preceding the establishment of a loss ratio floor.1 That would leave 20 cents of every premium dollar to cover salaries and other expenses, with room to cut costs like stock buybacks if companies want higher underwriting profits. Using that figure as a benchmark, Shearer recently found that P&C insurers are overcharging U.S. consumers by as much as $150 billion per year.

Examining home insurance loss ratios from 1988 to the first half of 2026, there has been a clear overall downward trend since the 1990s despite yearly fluctuations. This has left companies with a larger share of premium revenue to generate profits (see Chart 3)

Chart 3. Home Insurance Loss Ratios Have Trended Downward Since 1990s

Over the 35-year period between 1991 and 2025, the national average loss ratio was 65.6 percent. The net downward trend in loss ratios was most noticeable during the first three decades. From 1991 to 2000, the average loss ratio was 73.4 percent. During the next decade, 2001 to 2010, the average loss ratio fell to 63.2 percent. From 2011 to 2020, the average loss ratio declined even further, to 60.4 percent.2 This means that each decade, insurers paid out a progressively smaller share of the premiums they collected in claims.

More recently, between 2021 and 2025, the five-year average loss ratio was 65.4 percent. However, annual loss ratios fell significantly in 2024 and 2025, and preliminary data from the first half of this year suggest that another decrease is likely in 2026. The current downward trend reflects a combination of temporary meteorological luck and increasingly unscrupulous insurer practices, including coverage withdrawals, aggressive rate hikes, and claims denials.

A loss ratio of 65 percent leaves insurers with a 35 percent margin to cover operating expenses. A minimum loss ratio of 80 percent would require insurers to pay out at least 80 cents in claims for each premium dollar collected—five cents more than they did in the 1990s, 15 cents more than they have over the past decade, and 25 cents more than they did in 2025. That would bring payouts closer to historical levels: In the 1990s, home insurance industry loss ratios averaged 74 percent. An 80 percent minimum, while higher than the 1990s average, is an appropriate benchmark because insurers have long benefited from a patchwork system of weak rate regulation that allows them to overcharge and shortchange consumers in many states, obtaining unreasonably high profits in the process. 

As climate change increases the frequency and severity of extreme weather, homeowners are likely to face more damage and turn to their insurer more often, necessitating stronger consumer protections. Insurers can absorb mounting damages with an 80 percent minimum loss ratio and still have a 20 percent margin to cover necessary operating costs and maintain adequate reserves and surplus. They may, however, have to reduce frivolous spending on things like advertising, outlandish executive pay packages and perks, and shareholder dividends, expenses that insurance regulators could cap outright to prevent unnecessary premium increases.

Using NAIC data on annual home insurance premiums and loss ratios, we calculated total underwriting income before expenses from 2021 to 2025. We estimate excess underwriting income each year by contrasting actual underwriting performance against a counterfactual scenario in which an 80 minimum loss ratio exists.

From 2021 to 2025, U.S. insurers collected $725.5 billion in home insurance premiums. Based on annual nationwide loss ratios, we estimate that during that five-year period, insurers generated $258 billion in underwriting income after paying claims. Compared with a minimum loss ratio of 80 percent, insurers generated an estimated $112.8 billion in excess underwriting income over the past five years (see Chart 4 and Table 3).

Those gains were especially pronounced in 2025, when the national loss ratio was just 55.1 percent. In contrast to a scenario with an 80 percent loss ratio, excess underwriting income reached $45 billion. The pattern was similar in 2024. With a national loss ratio of 61.5 percent, insurers overcharged and underpaid consumers by $30 billion.

Chart 4. Excess Underwriting Income Reached $113 Billion, 2021-2025

Table 3. Excess Underwriting Income Reached $113 Billion, 2021-2025

30 Percent of Home Insurance Claims Were Denied

Insurance companies are also maximizing profits by closing a staggering number of claims without payment. A recent investigation by the Wall Street Journal found that the five largest home insurers failed to pay out anything in more than 44 percent of claims closed last year. That means that despite paying premiums for years, many policyholders still do not receive the money they are owed when disasters hit. 

From 2021 to 2025, the share of claims insurers closed without paying anything averaged 29.9 percent nationwide, according to data from the NAIC. Last year, the ratio reached or exceeded 30 percent in 33 states. Over the five-year period, Washington D.C. saw the highest rate of claims closed without payment over this period (37%), followed by Vermont (35%), Maine (34%), Alaska (34%), and California (34%) (see Table 4). 

While the NAIC data cover the entire market within each state, the Wall Street Journal analysis examined claims handled solely by the five largest homeowners’ insurers. Its higher rates suggest that claim nonpayment may actually be worse among those companies than across the market as a whole.

Lower claims payouts also reflect reduced coverage, as insurers dropped some existing policies, raised deductibles and capped coverage on others, and stopped covering perils like wind and hail in certain regions. Homeowners may now need two or three separate policies to fully insure their home, and may need to navigate different insurers, billing systems, and claims processes in the event of a disaster.

Table 4. Home Insurance Claim Denial Rate, 2021-2025

22 Percent of Home Insurance Claims Were Delayed

Insurers also profit by delaying claims payments. This allows them to keep premiums invested in income-generating assets for longer, while policyholders are forced to delay rebuilding or repair following a disaster. The Consumer Federation of America and Weiss Ratings estimate that for each day homeowners insurance companies delay claims payments, the industry collectively takes in an extra $8.8 million in interest and investment income. 

Nationwide, the average percentage of claims paid out beyond 60 days was 22.6 percent in 2025 and 22.4 percent in the five year period between 2021 to 2025. The percentage of claims paid out beyond 60 days varied significantly by state, ranging from 13 percent (West Virginia) to 42 percent (Florida) in 2025, and from 14 percent (West Virginia) to 44 percent (Florida) over the last five years (see Table 5). After Florida, the states with the greatest share of claims paid beyond 60 days in the 2021 to 2025 period were Hawaii (37%), California (31%), Louisiana (29%), and Alaska (28%). Florida and Hawaii are noticeable outliers, with the share of claims paid beyond 60 days falling well above the national average. 

Table 5. Home Insurance Claim Delay Rate, 2021-2025

Top 10 Home Insurers Increased Premium Revenue by 63 Percent as Their Loss Ratios Fell by 23 Percent

The following 10 insurance companies have earned the most premium revenue from U.S. homeowners and renters over the past five years: State Farm, Allstate, USAA, Liberty Mutual, Farmers, Travelers, American Family, Chubb, Nationwide, and Progressive. Collectively, their premium revenue grew by 63.4 percent during the study period, from $71.5 billion to $116.9 billion (see Table 6).

With the exception of Nationwide, each of the largest carriers increased premium revenue by at least 40 percent over the past five years. Leading the way was American Family, which more than doubled the amount of premiums it earned over the period, from $4.7 billion in 2021 to $9.7 billion in 2025. American Family’s market share grew modestly during those years, from 4.2 percent to 5.1 percent.

Table 6. Top 10 Home Insurers Increased Premium Revenue by 63 percent, 2021-2025

Loss ratios for the top 10 U.S. home insurers decreased by 22.8 percent during the same period, from an average of 69.2 percent in 2021 to 53.4 percent in 2025 (see Table 7). Last year, five of the companies had loss ratios under 50 percent: Liberty Mutual (49.9%), Farmers (48.8%), American Family (44.4%), Nationwide (38.2%), and Progressive (28.1%). 

The lowest five-year average loss ratios among the top 10 firms were held by Chubb (56.3%), Progressive (56.5%), Farmers (60.4%), Liberty Mutual (61.2%), and American Family (63.3%).

These firms saw the biggest reductions in loss ratios from 2021 to 2025: Progressive (64% decrease), Nationwide (47% decrease), Farmers (31% decrease), American Family (29% decrease), Liberty Mutual (24% decrease) and Allstate (24% decrease).

Table 7. Top 10 Home Insurers’ Loss Ratios Fell by 23 percent, 2021-2025
  1. Shearer’s analysis covers the entire P&C industry, which includes auto, commercial liability, and other lines in addition to home insurance. We have limited our analysis to home insurance policy lines, which include multi-peril homeowners insurance (the most common type of home insurance), manufactured home insurance, renters insurance, and condo owner insurance. 
    ↩︎
  2. Reinsurance costs rose sharply in recent years due to increasing risk of severe climate disasters. However, these have had a modest effect on loss ratios trends, according to NAIC profitability reports. Home insurance net loss ratios, which factor in reinsurance costs and payouts, averaged 74.1 percent in the 1990s, 63.7 percent in the 2000s, 61.5 percent in the 2010s, and 67.7 percent in the 2020s. The discrepancy between net loss ratios and direct loss ratios reached around 2 percent in the 2020s, and reflects additional underwriting income that the reinsurance industry is capturing. ↩︎

Report: Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis

For years, homeowners have been told skyrocketing insurance premiums are an inevitable consequence of climate change and inflation. Insurers have blamed more frequent and costly disasters for aggressively raising rates and withdrawing from markets.

This report lays out how the latest data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows soaring insurance costs cannot be fully explained by rising climate impacts, reinsurance, or construction costs. Excessive industry spending on overhead like executive compensation, advertising, and shareholder dividends, and record high profits are also to blame for climbing insurance prices. Meanwhile, insurers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for.

Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis was written by (alphabetically) Alex Martin, Dustin Duong, Elyse Schupak, Kenny Stancil, Lois Parshley, Mekedas Belayneh. It was edited by Aditi Sen, Annie Norman, David Arkush, and Jeff Hauser and published in November 2026.

Report Logos