Every year, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) publishes data on loss ratios across states, companies, and lines of business in its market share reports.
Our methodology uses direct loss ratios, which exclude reinsurance costs and payouts, to evaluate whether insurance companies are charging too much for premiums. This ratio measures the percentage of premiums insurers pay out in claims, revealing how much premium revenue remains for other expenses and profits. Direct loss ratios are the best measure for the value consumers are getting. A lower loss ratio means a smaller share of the premiums collected returns to policyholders through claims payouts, which ultimately reflects the efficiency of the sector in returning capital back to policyholders, the main purpose of insurance.
The money that does not go toward claims supports expenses, including advertising campaigns built around the familiar jingles and mascots of major insurers, reinsurance, legal costs associated with denying policyholders’ claims, and other overhead. Companies also direct substantial sums toward dividends, stock buybacks, and executive compensation, alongside costly perks such as State Farm’s four private jets.
Our methodology applies an 80 percent loss ratio benchmark as the basis for evaluating how much premium revenue insurers pocket as excess profits rather than pay out in claims. We use an 80 percent loss ratio benchmark because the objective is not simply to identify unusually low ratios, but to establish a meaningful standard for ensuring that policyholders receive value for their premiums. This threshold is comparable to the federal minimum loss ratio requirements for health insurers, which require insurers to spend at least 80 percent of premium revenue on health care claims. The major difference between P&C insurance and health insurance is that major loss events can cause greater year-to-year variability in P&C loss ratios, making that higher benchmark harder to meet annually. But, in recent years, P&C insurers’ use of reinsurance has helped mitigate this variability, with net loss ratios remaining more consistent year-to-year. Historically, P&C insurers have had higher loss ratios, averaging around 74 percent in the 1990s, not far off from an 80 percent benchmark.
Even with a benchmark for loss ratios, the metric is not immune from being manipulated to represent inflated losses. Net loss ratios are calculated including reinsurance costs, which create issues of non-competitive profits earned by reinsurers and the skimming of premiums by some insurers to affiliated reinsurers as well as other affiliated business arrangements for other parts of the insurance life cycle. Without clear definitions of “losses” in the ratio, insurers could inflate reported losses by classifying ordinary overhead, legal fees, and administrative costs as loss-adjustment expenses. This is particularly murky because insurers may own affiliates that handle claims or provide reinsurance. By inflating payments to these affiliates, insurers can manipulate direct or net loss ratios while shifting profits to related companies. This has occurred in both California, where State Farm overpaid for reinsurance, and Florida, where insurers have repeatedly overpaid affiliated companies for administrative services.
Loss ratios are not a one-to-one measure of whether insurers are shortchanging policyholders on claims payments. They are rough measures, and the way insurers classify costs and calculate these numbers can make it hard to see where the money actually goes. These limitations do not negate the value of loss ratios as a tool for understanding insurer profitability and assessing how much premium revenue insurers retain rather than pay out in claims. They can be a useful starting point to scrutinize the excess costs insurers use to obscure money flowing to executives, affiliated companies, and excessive marketing—costs ultimately borne by policyholders.
Report: Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis
For years, homeowners have been told skyrocketing insurance premiums are an inevitable consequence of climate change and inflation. Insurers have blamed more frequent and costly disasters for aggressively raising rates and withdrawing from markets.
This report lays out how the latest data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows soaring insurance costs cannot be fully explained by rising climate impacts, reinsurance, or construction costs. Excessive industry spending on overhead like executive compensation, advertising, and shareholder dividends, and record high profits are also to blame for climbing insurance prices. Meanwhile, insurers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for.
Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis was written by (alphabetically) Alex Martin, Dustin Duong, Elyse Schupak, Kenny Stancil, Lois Parshley, Mekedas Belayneh. It was edited by Aditi Sen, Annie Norman, David Arkush, and Jeff Hauser and published in November 2026.